The popular 3DBenchy template, a globally used benchmark model for 3D printers, is currently causing discussion in the community. The background to this is the more consistent enforcement of the model’s original license by platforms such as Printables. This is based on the Creative Commons BY-ND 4.0 license, which allows use and distribution but prohibits the modification and publication of derivative works.
Initial reports about the removal of 3DBenchy remixes appeared on Reddit, where users shared screenshots of conversations with the Printables support team. The platform justified the removal with license violations and confirmed that all derived models would be reviewed in the future and deleted if necessary.
Interestingly, however, it turned out that the rights holders, the NTI Group, did not actively enforce the license. Prusa Research, the company behind Printables, also confirmed that a third party had initiated the review, without providing further details.
The debate highlights the complexity of Creative Commons licenses in practice. While the original license rules provide clear guidelines, enforcement often remains difficult. The community had a mixed reaction: while some users respect the strict implementation of the license, others fear a negative impact on creativity and open exchange in the 3D printing scene.
Daniel Norée, the designer behind 3DBenchy, expressed regret about the current situation in a LinkedIn post. He pointed out that the takeover of Creative Tools by NTI Group last year had changed the rights situation, which may have contributed to the misunderstandings.
The first users are already designing alternative test models and 3DBenchy alternatives. For example, 3D BOATY can be found on Printables. A small bench designed to serve as a 3D printing test.
Subscribe to our Newsletter
3DPresso is a weekly newsletter that links to the most exciting global stories from the 3D printing and additive manufacturing industry.
